| Chiffon | Chrissy Doba |
| Crystal | Danielle Moreno |
| Ronnette | Aimee Lucus |
| Mushnik | Joe Maniglia |
| Audrey | Abigail Stokley |
| Seymour | Zach Mauck / AJ Maniglia |
| Orin (Bernstein, Snip Luce, Martin) | Stephen Root |
| Audrey II (Puppeteer Pods 1 & 2) | Kelsey Hontz |
| Puppeteer Pods 3 & 4 | Sean Meehan |
| Voice | Evan Luthye |
| Ensemble | Kelsey Hontz Areya Kugler Paige Latendresse Patrick Penland |
